Proposed Modernisation of the Scottish Civil Justice System 30/9/09

Legal Updates Filter

Use as many of the search criteria as you wish to find the article you are looking for

 

 

 

 

One of Scotland’s most senior judges the Lord Justice Clerk, Lord Gill, today published his report on the Scottish Civil Justice System following a two year review of structure, jurisdiction, procedures and working methods.

The most significant recommendations are as follows:-

Structure of civil court system 
Only claims worth above £150,000 will be litigated in the Court of Session.

A specialist national personal injury court should be established in Edinburgh but with the continued right of any personal injury claimant to sue in the local Sheriff Court. The claimant will have the choice of local access to justice or the advantages of a dedicated specialist court. Civil jury trials should be extended to the new specialist personal injury court only.

A number of sheriffs will be designated as specialists in personal injury litigation.

A new judicial office of district judge should be created. A district judge would sit in the Sheriff Court and hear civil claims with a value of £5,000 or less. This will be based on an interventionist approach and will replace the current Summary Cause and Small Claim procedure.

In the Court of Session where the claimant is awarded a sum less than £150,000, costs should be awarded on the Sheriff Court scale unless the claimant can show reasons why it was necessary to raise an action in the Court of Session.

A rule should be introduced enabling a tender (i.e. part 36 offer) of a value below £150,000 to be accompanied by an offer of Sheriff Court costs in full and final settlement of the claim.

A new case management model
An overriding principle of the court should be that it would have power to control the conduct and pace of all cases before it.

On entering a defence, a case should be allocated to a particular judge or sheriff who wherever practicable, will deal with all hearings for that case.

In the Sheriff Court, a form of case-flow management will apply to personal injury actions under new rules to come into effect on 2 November 2009. These are broadly similar to the current court rules which apply to personal injury actions in the Court of Session.

Facilitating settlement
Compliance with the current pre-action protocol in relation to personal injury and industrial disease claims should be compulsory.

The courts should have the power to make orders in relation to costs and interest for non-compliance with pre-action protocols.

Judicial tenders (i.e. Part 36 offers) should be replaced by a rule regulating the making of formal offers. Any party would be entitled to make a monetary or non-monetary offer in full or partial settlement before or after the commencement of an action. Such an offer, if not accepted, would have implications regarding costs.

A party making an offer should be able to specify a time limit for acceptance.

Enhanced case management
The report makes recommendations for enhancing the court’s case management powers, including early disclosure of documents, greater use of witness statements in place of oral testimony, abbreviated written pleadings and the appropriate use of expert evidence.

Multi-party actions (i.e. “class actions”)
There should be a special procedure for dealing with multiple claims in the Court of Session.

The court should be satisfied that: the applicant of one group of persons claim gives rise to common or similar issues of fact or law; the adoption of group procedure is preferable; and that the applicant is an appropriate person to be appointed as a representative party.

The court should be satisfied that the claimants have demonstrated a prima facie cause of action.

The court will also need powers to make a global award of damages.

The cost and funding of litigation 
There should be a significant increase in the recoverable fee for pre-litigation work to reflect work properly and reasonably carried out in connection with investigation and intimation of a claim, discussion on settlement and compliance with pre-action protocol.

There should be a judicial table of fees for counsel in Court of Session and Sheriff Court (where sanction for counsel is given).

Legal aid should be available, subject to usual tests, for all types and values of proceedings under simplified procedure.

Summary
It will be for the Scottish Ministers to decide how to take forward the recommendations made by Lord Gill. If the recommendations are implemented, in part or in full, they will radically overhaul the way in which civil cases are dealt with in Scotland. Parties to actions will have to be proactive to facilitate early resolution of disputes, make best use of resources and technology so as to ensure that cases are dealt with in proportion to their value, importance and complexity of the issues raised. 

Importantly for insurers:

  • the courts will have regard to pre-action offers when making awards of costs
  • claims worth less than £150,000 will be litigated in a more cost-effective forum
  • a new fast track for claims worth up to £5,000 will be created
  • jury trials for civil claims will continue and will be extended to the new national personal injury court.

We will update you again as soon as there are further developments.

To access a full copy of the report please click on the attached link:-
http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/civilcourtsreview/index.asp

Coming soon e-zine on new Sheriff Court personal injury action rules.

Further information
For further information on the issues raised in this ezine, please contact Andrew Lothian, Douglas Keir or your usual contact at Anderson Strathern.


This bulletin is for general information only and does not constitute legal, investment or other professional advice. Please contact us should you require advice on any particular legal issue. Anderson Strathern LLP accepts no responsibility for any loss that may arise if reliance is placed on any information or opinions expressed in this bulletin.